Most Undervalued Cleveland Guardians On 2025 Roster

Jim Tomlin Profile Picture

Can the Guardians keep getting the most out of their money in 2025? Last season, Cleveland won the American League Central and reached the AL Championship Series with a payroll aorund $100 million. And who are the best bargains on the current roster?

BetOhio.com, your source for top Ohio sportsbook promo codes, used Fangraphs.com to gather current salary information and projected 2025 WAR (Wins Above Replacement player). We then divided the 2025 salary by projected WAR for each player to determine potential value, as expressed by dollars per projected WAR point.

Must be 21+ to participate (18+ in KY). Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER (CO, IL, IA, KY, KS, LA, MD, MO, NC, NJ, OH, PA, TN, VA). Call 1-800-NEXT-STEP (AZ). Call 1-800-9-WITH-IT (IN). CALL 1-800-MY-RESET (OH). CALL 1-877-770-STOP (LA). Must be present in LA (select parishes). Licensee partner Amelia Belle Casino. Minimum $10 deposit required. Minimum odds -500 or greater. Bonus Bets wager excluded from returns. New customers only. T&Cs, time limits and exclusions apply.

Most Undervalued Cleveland Guardians on 2025 Roster

Player

2025 Salary

2025 Projected WAR

Value (Salary Per WAR) *

Bo Naylor (Catcher)

$800,000

2.8

$285,714

Tanner Bibee (Pitcher)

$800,000

2.6

$307,692

Brayan Rocchio (Shortstop)

$800,000

2.5

$320,000

*Rounded to nearest whole number

Note: Some salaries are represented by figures before arbitration. Only players projected on the Opening Day 40-man roster were included.

You can track Cleveland Guardians playoff chances all season with us at BetOhio.com.

Best Bargains For Cleveland Guardians

Catcher Bo Naylor is the best bargain on manager Stephen Vogt’s roster for 2025, according to our calculations. Using projected Wins Above Replacement from fangraphs.com and salary information, we calculate Naylor’s projected value for the upcoming season at $285,714 per WAR point. He’s set to earn $800,000 this season with a projected WAR of 2.8, which would be a career high.

Naylor (who turned 25 on Feb. 21) had 13 home runs and 39 RBIs in 389 plate appearances in 2024, his first full season in the majors as his team surprised many analysts and even Ohio MLB betting customers. This year he will be the lone Naylor in Cleveland because his older brother, first baseman Josh Naylor, has joined the Arizona Diamondbacks after five seasons with the Guardians.

The other two players on our list of bargains in Cleveland are also making $800,000 – that’s pitcher Tanner Bibee and shortstop Brayan Rocchio.

Must be 21+ and physically present in AZ, CO, IL, IN, IA, KS, KY, LA, ME, MD, MA, MI, MO, NJ, NY, NC, OH, PA, TN, VA, WV, WY or Washington, DC. New users only. Must register using eligible promo code. Min. qualifying bet amount: $1. Tokens max. bet amount: $25 per token. Tokens bet max. add'l winnings: $2,500 per token. Token(s) expire 14 days after receipt. Not reissued for voided/pushed bets. Void where prohibited. See Caesars.com/promos for full terms. Know When To Stop Before You StartĀ®. Gambling Problem? CO, IL, KY, MD, MI, MO, NJ, TN, VA, WV, WY, KS (Affiliated with Kansas Crossing Casino), ME (Licensed through the Mi’kmaq Nation, Penobscot Nation, and Houlton Band of Maliseet Indians, federally recognized tribes located in the State of Maine), NC (Licensed through Tribal Casino Gaming Enterprise), PA (Affiliated with Harrah's Philadelphia): If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, crisis counseling and referral services can be accessed by calling 1-800-GAMBLER (1-800-426-2537) or MD: visit mdgamblinghelp.org or WV: visit 1800gambler.net; AZ: Call 1-800-NEXT-STEP; IN: Call 1-800-9-WITH-IT; IA: Call 1-800-BETSOFF; MA: Call 1-800-327-5050 or visit gamblinghelplinema.org, NY: Call 877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369); LA (Licensed through Horseshoe Bossier City and Caesars New Orleans) Call 1-800-522-4700, Washington, DC (OLG Class A licensed Operator): Call 1-800-MY-RESET. Ā©2026, Caesars Entertainment

2025 Guardians Payroll Details

According to Spotrac.com, a site which tracks financial figures and player contracts, Cleveland goes into this season as one of eight teams with a projected payroll under $100 million, pegged at under $82.3 million. Compare that to the teams at the top such as the New York Mets (projected 2025 payroll $321.7 million), Los Angeles Dodgers ($292.9 million) and Philadelphia Phillies ($279.3M).

Ohio sportsbooks have reflected a feeling that perhaps last season’s success will not be repeated on the shores of Lake Erie. Cleveland has odds ranging between +275 and +300 to repeat as AL Central champions. Depending on which sportsbook you check, they’re either third or fourth on the board.

As far as winning the franchise’s first World Series championship since 1948, the moneyline on that outcome is as low as +2800 and as high as +4000 among various operators. If you have multiple accounts, it pays to shop around to get the best price for your wager.

For more insight on the Guardians, check out our story about how teams do after losing the League Championship Series, exclusively here at BetOhio.com.

USA Today photo by Joe Camporeale

Author

Jim Tomlin

Ohio native Jim Tomlin has 30 years of experience in journalism, mostly in sports. He lends his expertise to BetOhio.com as a writer and editor after previous experience at the Tampa Bay Times, FanRag, Saturday Down South and Saturday Tradition.

Cited by leading media organizations, such as: